This is a topic that comes up often on various knife forums. Which company is better, Benchmade or Spyderco? It is one of those questions that cannot really be answered because it comes down to personal preference, but it is fun to talk about.

A classic Spyderco and a classic Benchmade:

Benchmade and Spyderco have different things goes for them. Spyderco is all about spartan designs that are practical and ergonomic above being styish. Many Spyderco knives are traditionally ugly, but extremely functional and inexpensive. This makes them beautiful to the trained eye. Benchmade knives are functional and well-made, but tend to be a little more impressive visually. For example, look at the stunning Benchmade Skirmish (designed by Neil Blackwood):

Spyderco does not make anything as stunning as the Skirmish. But the Manix is less expensive, generally considered to be stronger, more comfortable, and is a better cutter. You make the call.

Benchmade also has the Axis lock, which many people love. It is easy to open and close with one hand, and very strong. It essentially has the ease of a liner lock with the strength of a lockback. However, Spyderco has many interesting locks as well, such as the Compression and Ball lock. Both of which are considered as good as the Axis lock by some people (but not all).

Benchmade also makes some very spartan “all business” knives, such as the Griptilian, which are more in-line with what Spyderco offers. Spyderco also makes more fancy knives, like the Kopa. So it should really just come down to which model appeals to you. Spyderco or Benchmade, both will make you happy and are well worth the price.